Cernos wrote:Classic Server should mean just that - the original DAOC with no expansions (though the upgraded graphics engine should be supported as the original one had some lovely memory leaks) and only the original base classes. It could be argued the rot started to set in with Shrounded Isles (Bonedancers, Savages, Animists, Necromancers all brought their different issues) and Spellcrafting (much more exciting when your resists are cobbled together from whatver drops you were lucky enough to find).
Of course the game had to progress for better or for worse, but for anyone wanting a nostalgic server then pure classic is the only way to go. Not putting the advanced classes into a pseudo classic server (how can you possibly justify a Vamp on a classic server without buffbots?).
Of course there's a lot of rose tinted memories and I bet anyone giving a pure classic server a try with the benefit of hindsight wouldn't tolerate many of the inadequacies, bugs, imbalances and flaws in the original game (things which were tolerated because we didn't know any better).
True. However, another analogy I'd like to make is this...
Of all the Star Trek series, the original series was the best, in my opinion. It was funnier, it was fresh, the technology wasn't perfect and it had lots of little quirks that made it what it was.
Then came the Next Generation... a different kettle of fish altogether. Klingons as allies? Give me a break! Jean Luc Picard? What a whimp... always asking his officers for their opinions.. what a way to command!
DS9... just a "Hollyoaks in Space"!
Voyager... everyone whinging about energy supplies and not being able to get their "Eggs Benedict" from the food replicator. Then Neelix cooking up something totally revolting from rats from the cargo hold and some strange fungal growth found growing in the plasma conduits!
Enterprise? Not bad, but the technology looked more advanced than the original series, when chronologically it was supposed to be inferior.
Anyway, the point is the original version was the best and I believe that to be true of DAoC.