The importance of being earnest... er honest

General 'Hibernian' forum for the entire cluster
User avatar
Cromcruaich
Posts: 1255
Joined: Mon Feb 07, 2005 5:59 pm
Location: North West, UK

Post by Cromcruaich »

Ovi wrote:Which are not open to public access? Therefore it isn't unreasonable for anyone with access to assume that anything posted would go no further?

Let's assume the Mods have a forum where you discussed this thread, and probably had a discussion about my input. Would you (and the other mods) be happy if someone took that and posted it here?

Would anyone in Hib be happy if someone posted details of a raid from the Secrets forum on FH?
Well to be frank, heirarchys around forums like the e&e forum have no reason not to be public. Infact its an insult that they are not and completely unneccessary. Unless you have a justifiable argument why you think that keriwin and takits and other e&e should be privy to information that the community isn't fit to see?

*edit
that isnt a dig at takits and keri btw, more illustration of why there is no need to even have the division
Crom, Druid of Na Fianna Dragun

If you have a problem, if no one else can help, and if you can find them, maybe you can hire...the A(nimist)-Team

Cue music for full effect.

Thanks to Tuthmes for the link.

User avatar
HappyG
Emerald Rider
Posts: 418
Joined: Mon Feb 14, 2005 9:21 am
Location: Slovenia

Post by HappyG »

Ovi wrote:Which are not open to public access? Therefore it isn't unreasonable for anyone with access to assume that anything posted would go no further?
Following the events of the past days, I think we have all learned: "If its not in the CoC/2 side agreement/any kind of legal crap like that, it doesn't exist!". If GOA didn't sign any kind of agreement with E&Es about this, I see it perfectly clear E&Es can do whatever they want with it :) Populistic? Yes, but so it is, when relations come down so deep, both parties feel the need to quote the contract :)
Hep, treated MMORPG addict, on the way to master his uni
Morana, one of a few Rangers, that did not Zerg. Retired for good.

User avatar
Sharkith
Posts: 2910
Joined: Mon Feb 07, 2005 12:08 pm

Post by Sharkith »

Ovi wrote: Whilst we may not have known "from the horses mouth", we certainly knew it from the evidence in front of us.
excatly Ovi we suspected it and there was evidence to indicate it. But at a time when everyone is low, fed up and on a short fuse wouldn't it go some way to repair that lost confidence. Ok don't shout at me about this but I have shifed my attention to Eve now. This is one of the reasons why:

This is taken from Eve's development blog - they had trouble with their first issue of EON a magazine solely dedicated to their game:
Zapatero of EON wrote: The second issue of E-ON is now available for pre-order. The magazine is scheduled for publication early in January 2006, which means buyers can expect to receive their copies sometime before 2007 (j/k).

Let’s not beat about the bush, the late arrival of the magazine was something of a disappointment for quite a few people. It appears nearly everyone now has their copies of issue #001, but the fact that it took up to six weeks when it should have taken no more than a couple at most is embarrassing. I can only apologize once again and assure you that the same problems won’t re-occur.

For those who have faith in my assurances, we have decided to employ a different mailing house and rely (which we can) on the services of the UK’s Royal Mail. The upshot of this is that the cost of postage will rise slightly for some. Effective immediately, the postage price per issue for European customers will rise by 36 US cents, whilst for the USA and elsewhere this figure will increase by 35 US cents. UK postal rates remain the same. Those of you that have already subscribed will not have to pay any extra for postage, but we would ask everyone to allow up to three weeks for delivery (three weeks being the worst case scenario).

For those of you for which three weeks is too long, and who wish to take it up, we have arranged a deal with FedEx and can now offer an express shipping option. The cost of this is $24.30 per issue. Expensive yes, but you will be able to track your order (using a tracking number which will be emailed to you upon shipment) and you will receive the magazine within two working days of publication date or order, whichever is the latter. This offer is only available to European, Canadian or US residents. Those living outside these areas who wish to take advantage of the express shipping option or current subscribers who wish to upgrade their postal options to express shipping can do so by emailing eon@mmmpublishing.

There is another reason for the postage price rise, apart from us using Royal Mail to deliver the goods: E-ON Issue #002 will be BIGGER, with the number of pages increasing from 68 to 76. It gets better: for those that pre-order a subscription before 4th January 2006, we will be treating you to a set of six exclusive postcard prints of rare ships. (Those who have already taken out a 4-issue subscription will also be receiving these cards, but thereafter we do not plan to backdate subscription offers.)

Delays aside, E-ON #001 was a great success. Feedback has been worryingly positive. I say worryingly because, having played EVE so long, alarm bells start ringing when players are content about something. To offset my paranoia we’re going all out to improve the magazine in terms of variety and content. Of course there have been a few negative comments too, but all those who’ve posted feedback have been more than constructive and I would like to thank you all]

The first issue was a PR disaster - and look they admit it and are open about it. Most of the comments in response to this are positive.

Now why could GOA not have come clean with us and just have said it clearly and openly. We get vague communication and all it does is promote damaging speculation. The fact that someone confirms our suspicions is what this thread achieves. It is done at a moral cost because thats what happens when people blow thw whistle. Now you might feel that we did not gain enough to justify this. That would be a fair assessment. It is however Keirwins choice.

Sharkith
Na Fianna Dragun

Karak-Eight Peaks, Kiera ze Witch Hunter

Eve online - Kaminjosvig.

User avatar
Sharkith
Posts: 2910
Joined: Mon Feb 07, 2005 12:08 pm

Post by Sharkith »

Cromcruaich wrote:Well to be frank, heirarchys around forums like the e&e forum have no reason not to be public. Infact its an insult that they are not and completely unneccessary. Unless you have a justifiable argument why you think that keriwin and takits and other e&e should be privy to information that the community isn't fit to see?

*edit
that isnt a dig at takits and keri btw, more illustration of why there is no need to even have the division
I completely agree with this. Openess is good speculation is dangerous.

Ovi
Emerald Rider
Posts: 952
Joined: Mon Feb 07, 2005 1:13 pm

Post by Ovi »

Cromcruaich wrote:Well to be frank, heirarchys around forums like the e&e forum have no reason not to be public. Infact its an insult that they are not and completely unneccessary. Unless you have a justifiable argument why you think that keriwin and takits and other e&e should be privy to information that the community isn't fit to see?

*edit
that isnt a dig at takits and keri btw, more illustration of why there is no need to even have the division
That isn't the point. The point is, given that they are private and restricted, the content should not be taken and quoted elsewhere.

Whether the content should be restricted is a different discussion.

User avatar
Quinlan
Posts: 1505
Joined: Tue Feb 08, 2005 12:00 pm
Location: Variable

Post by Quinlan »

Ovi wrote:That isn't the point. The point is, given that they are private and restricted, the content should not be taken and quoted elsewhere.

Whether the content should be restricted is a different discussion.
It is not private. There is no NDA or anything signed by the E&E to not disclose that information. GOA is good at quoting contracts.. E&E can be good at that too since there is none
finland:
holland:

User avatar
Gahn
Posts: 778
Joined: Sun Feb 06, 2005 10:39 am

Post by Gahn »

Quinlan wrote:It is not private. There is no NDA or anything signed by the E&E to not disclose that information. GOA is good at quoting contracts.. E&E can be good at that too since there is none
xD
Gahn LoneWolf Celt Seraph Tiarna Prydwen
Na Fianna Dragun
Gahn Lonewolf Guardian [TDA] on Gunnar's Hold

Ovi
Emerald Rider
Posts: 952
Joined: Mon Feb 07, 2005 1:13 pm

Post by Ovi »

Quinlan wrote:It is not private. There is no NDA or anything signed by the E&E to not disclose that information. GOA is good at quoting contracts.. E&E can be good at that too since there is none

Legally and Morally right are 2 different things. By that logic we can post anything from the secrets forum on FH without a probelm. I suspect that would incur significantly more flaming though for some reason :o

awarkle
Emerald Rider
Posts: 125
Joined: Mon Feb 07, 2005 1:22 am

Post by awarkle »

well from my experiences as being an E&e most of the forum stuff is generaly about either problems with the servers aka an artis gone wrong, bug abusers, and future patch testing.

If the goa forums were open and people read that i had seen xxx player obviously speed hacking across the realm the whole forum would turn into a name and blame game.

Or testing for a future patch or a goa event if everyone could read that where would the fun be. I read information which might help me in helping you, if goa choose to supply that information to me. They dont have to really tell us anything about anything they didnt have to inform the player base about the prydwen crash they could have said "yeah we lost some items tough luck" but they explained what happened to the e&e's. OK its not the best way and there isnt reason why the GM's cant just explain it without the e&e's but we are there as volunteers. Im an E&e to help the game run smoothly if that means i try and get cheaters banned AKA speed hack, radar, geometry abuse does that make me a bad person ?

the thing is the forums when we say Btw we think xxx player is cheating it means that us e&e's even if we are on the same server can either keep and eye on them or notice them from the other realm when we are fighting them. OR bug exploits there is one which im aware of that i could exploit quite a bit but im aware of it and i suspect other players are aware of it but at least i can look for the signs of the exploit and if necessary pm them and tell them to stop. They dont have to listen to me and noone does im not a GM im not employed by goa im just someone who is trying to keep the game fair. Like you all should be doing.

people will say what they want i just think this whole episode has probbaly ruined a lot of peoples view of other people.

If you love the game and enjoy the comunity then fair enough voice your concerns but dont go on a crusade to ruin it for other people.

If your just here to troll and ruin it for other people then i would say your not a person i would like to group with.
Albion : Arod (tic) Ponies (cleric)
Midgard : Cavewark(sham), Augwark(healer), cursiara(warlock), mistieral(valkyrie)
Hibernia : Bastilia (vamp)
Albion (glast) : Zalasta (sorc) awark(wiz) mincer (minstrel) + others
DAOC E&E find me on any char for assistance.

User avatar
Gattling
Emerald Rider
Posts: 42
Joined: Mon Aug 22, 2005 7:46 am
Location: Holland

Post by Gattling »

Finally, some common sense.
Gattling - ML10 RR3 ranger <-- easy RPS :ranger:
Phenomenal - 50 ML5 RR2 Druid
Soraellion - 50 Mentalist
Skilless - 3~ Bard

<Tuatha dé Danann>


various Thid toons
various Alb/Excal toons

Post Reply

Return to “Hibernian Cluster Discussion”